DocsUser guideReview & decide

Review & decide

Decisions are two steps on purpose: stage them all, read the list once, then send.

  1. Open Submissions. Two rows of tabs: what a thing IS, then where it stands.

    The Devcon Berlin submissions inbox with kind tabs, status tabs and one pending proposal
    Top row: All · Abstracts · Sessions. Second row: the pipeline. Search and a track filter sit above the table.

    Abstracts arrived through one of your forms and are waiting on you. Sessions are things you added yourself — keynotes, sponsor slots, breaks — and they start out accepted. The second row is the pipeline every abstract moves along: All, Accepted, Accept Queue, Pending, Decline Queue, Declined, Withdrawn, Drafts. The two combine, so “Abstracts + Pending” is one click.

  2. Click a row to read the whole thing. The drawer has five tabs: Details, People, Reviews, Files and History.

    The submission drawer for the Devcon Berlin proposal, with Details, People, Reviews, Files and History tabs
    Everything is editable in place, including the status pill at the top.
  3. Click that status pill and pick where it goes. One click applies it — there is no Save.

    The status picker open: Accepted, Accept Queue, Pending, Decline Queue, Declined, Withdrawn and Draft, with a note that queue statuses don't email anyone until you send the queue
    The same picker sits in every row of the table, so triage is one click per submission. A toast confirms each one, and re-picking is one click back.

    That is safe because picking a queue only stages the decision — the note at the bottom of the picker says so. The speaker sees nothing, hears nothing, and their portal keeps saying Pending. The list here is your own: rename the built-ins or add one of your own (a “Waitlist”, say) under Event settings → Statuses, reachable from the gear in the picker’s corner.

  4. A banner counts what is staged. Read the queue one last time — this is the only moment it costs nothing to change your mind.

    The Accept Queue tab with one staged proposal and a banner counting it
    Tick several rows to stage them in one go: a bar appears with the same statuses on it.
  5. Press “Send acceptances” (or “Send declines”) and confirm.

    The confirmation dialog before sending the acceptances
    The dialog counts what is going out. Accepted speakers also get their onboarding tasks created.
  6. At a real event this table runs to hundreds of rows — same tabs, same two-step decision, plus filters to cut it down.

    A busier event's submissions table, filtered to accepted talks in one track, showing scores and speakers
    A different, busier event, narrowed to Accepted in one track. The counts on both tab rows always report the whole event.
Sending is the point of no return for the speaker — the email has left. The status can still be changed afterwards, but the message cannot be unsent.
Running a scored review with a panel? That lives under Evaluation: bundle evaluators, submissions and rounds into a plan, and each evaluator gets their own “My evaluations” link.